If you are bracing for a room where people you love no longer agree about much, the research has more to offer than a plea to keep the peace.
You know roughly how the evening goes. There is the person who will start it, the person who cannot let it go, and the three or four people who will spend the meal managing the temperature of the room. Maybe you have already decided to say nothing. Maybe you have decided that before, and it has not always worked.
This article names no issue and takes no side. What follows is what the research says about rooms like that one.
Common enough to show up as a national health statistic. In the American Psychological Association's Stress in America survey for 2025, fielded in August 2025, 62 percent of adults named division in the country as a significant source of stress and 76 percent named the future of the nation.
The more useful finding is what that correlates with at home. Comparing adults who named division as a significant stressor against those who did not: 60 percent against 49 percent had lost patience with or yelled at a family member, 55 percent against 37 percent had canceled social plans, and 61 percent against 43 percent felt isolated often or some of the time. Survey data taken at one moment, so read it as a pattern rather than a cause. But the pattern is clear. Whatever is happening out there arrives in the kitchen.
In a separate poll taken in November 2025, 32 percent of adults said they were worried about challenging family dynamics over the holidays, while 61 percent named seeing family and friends as what they most looked forward to. Looking forward to it and worrying about it can sit side by side.
Less often than the conversation about it suggests.
Roughly 27 percent of US adults report a current estrangement from a family member, according to a nationally representative survey of 1,340 adults from Cornell's family reconciliation research. But when researchers ask why, the answers are older and more personal than the news cycle. Karl Pillemer's pathways are harsh parenting, abuse or neglect, favoritism and sibling conflict, loss of contact after a divorce, in-law conflict, conflict over wills and money, disapproval of a relative's core values, and norm violations. Disapproval of core values is one pathway among several. A separate interview study found that cutting contact was typically a last resort after years of mistreatment rather than an impulsive decision.
Estrangement is also often not permanent. In a large longitudinal study of adult children, 81 percent of mother estrangements and 69 percent of father estrangements concluded in reconciliation. Every family is different, and for some people distance is the healthier choice, but a hard evening is rarely the last word.
Research on family distancing describes estrangement as a continuum with many separate dials: how much you talk, how often, how far apart you live, how much warmth is present. Not one switch. You can turn down one dial without touching the others, which is roughly the definition of getting through a holiday. And avoidance itself is not automatically corrosive. A study of parent and child pairs and dating couples found the link between avoiding a topic and relational dissatisfaction depended on why people were avoiding it, supporting the conclusion that avoidance can be benign and even helpful in some circumstances. Deciding to leave something alone to protect a relationship you both want is a different act from going silent because you have given up on being understood.
Choosing not to argue is one thing. Hiding every reaction all evening is another, and the research on that is unflattering.
In a laboratory study, pairs of people discussed an upsetting topic while one of them either suppressed their emotional expression, responded naturally, or deliberately reinterpreted the situation. Suppression disrupted communication, reduced rapport, and magnified blood pressure responses in the suppressors' partners as well as in the suppressors themselves. Reappraisal, changing what you tell yourself the conversation means, did not carry those costs.
A prospective study of students across a term adds the long view. Habitual suppression predicted lower social support from friends, less closeness to others and lower social satisfaction, after controlling for baseline support. It showed no relationship with how much people liked them. Which is exactly why we all keep doing it. Suppression lets you pass. It may make it harder to feel close to anyone.
One more finding will land for anyone with a specific relative in mind. Where participants brought either a supportive friend or an ambivalent one to a stressful task, the ambivalent friend produced higher cardiovascular reactivity that persisted into recovery. That was a small laboratory study of young adults and friends rather than family, so treat it as a hint: relationships that mix affection and tension can be especially stressful.
Four things with real support behind them.
Signal respect for their values, explicitly. In a study of families divided by deep disagreement, communicating respect for the other person's values was the most influential of all the accommodating strategies tested, and among the strategies most damaged by the disagreement itself.
Use the words that signal receptiveness. This is learnable, works whatever the topic, and was tested across several studies. Four moves: say things positively rather than as negations, explicitly acknowledge that you understand the other person, name actual points of agreement, and hedge rather than speak in absolutes. People who did this were seen as more persuasive and as better future partners. The uncomfortable finding alongside it: people's own ratings of how receptive they were being did not track their behavior. You cannot feel your way to this. You have to use the words, something like: "I know this matters to you. I see it differently, and I would rather not debate it tonight."
Ask rather than imagine. Across 25 experiments, instructing people to take another's perspective did not improve their accuracy about what that person thought or felt. It sometimes made them more confident. Accuracy improved when people simply got the other person's perspective by asking. Putting yourself in their shoes can make you more certain without making you more correct.
Decide your exit before you arrive. The general psychology of follow-through is clear: people who decide in advance exactly what they will do when a specific situation arises are substantially more likely to do it. That research is about goal pursuit broadly, not family dinners. But "if it turns to that, I will say I would rather not get into it and go help in the kitchen" is far more likely to happen than a resolution to stay calm. Nadine Kaslow, a past president of the American Psychological Association, recommends exactly these lines, plus a deliberate redirect to traditions and old memories and a brief pause outside when things escalate. One small Arizona advantage in November: stepping outside for ten minutes is genuinely pleasant here, which makes the pause easier to take and harder to read as a storm-out. And if someone is insulting or threatening you, or keeps ignoring a line you have drawn, leaving early or not going at all is a reasonable plan.
Across three studies with nearly 1,100 participants, family rituals went with more holiday enjoyment, through greater family closeness and greater involvement. The specific ritual did not matter much. Performing it as a group did, and individual rituals showed no meaningful effect. The finding that matters here: the link held independently of how much participants actually liked their family members.
That inverts the usual advice. You do not have to feel warm toward everyone in order to get something out of the evening. What counted was doing the thing together. Make the same bad pie. Keep the walk after dinner. In these studies, the shared doing went along with more closeness, even for people who did not especially like their relatives.
And if the gathering is not one you can face this year, spending the day with people you choose is not a consolation prize. In one study of older LGBTQ+ adults in Israel, having more chosen-family members was associated with fewer depressive symptoms and better wellbeing. We wrote about that in The Family You Find Along the Way.
If you are losing sleep over a date on the calendar, or carrying a grief about a relationship that used to be easier, that is a reasonable thing to take to a therapist, and November is a sensible time to do it rather than January.
The Healing Effect works with clients across Arizona, in person and by telehealth for clients located in the state. You can read more on our life transitions page, or get in touch through our contact form.
And hold onto the finding from the APA survey that is easy to miss. In the same study where division was a stressor for most people, 92 percent agreed that relationships are a key source of meaning and purpose in their lives, with family named most often. For many people, the room is hard because it still matters.
In person or by telehealth, for clients located in Arizona.
In an American Psychiatric Association poll of 2,203 US adults fielded in November 2025, 32 percent said they were worried about dealing with challenging family dynamics over the holidays. In the American Psychological Association's 2025 Stress in America survey, 62 percent of adults named division in the country as a significant source of stress, and those who did were more likely than others to report having lost patience with or yelled at a family member.
Usually not on its own. Around 27 percent of US adults report a current estrangement, and the documented pathways are harsh parenting, abuse or neglect, parental favoritism and sibling conflict, loss of contact after divorce, in-law conflict, conflict over money and inheritance, disapproval of a relative's core values, and violations of expected behavior. Interview research also finds that going no-contact is usually a last resort after years of mistreatment.
It depends on your reason. Research on parent and child pairs and dating couples found that the link between topic avoidance and dissatisfaction was moderated by people's motivations for avoiding, and that avoidance can be benign or even helpful in some circumstances. Avoiding a subject to protect a relationship you both want is different from going silent because you have given up.
Suppressing emotion has measurable social costs. In a laboratory study, people instructed to suppress their emotional expression during a difficult conversation showed disrupted communication and reduced rapport, and raised blood pressure responses in their conversation partners as well as themselves. Reinterpreting the situation beforehand did not carry those costs.
Shared rituals do. Across three studies with nearly 1,100 participants, family rituals went with more holiday enjoyment through greater closeness and involvement. The specific ritual mattered less than doing it as a group, and the link held regardless of how much participants liked their family members.
Sources:
American Psychological Association and The Harris Poll. Stress in America 2025: A Crisis of Connection, November 2025 (62 percent naming societal division a significant source of stress; 76 percent naming the future of the nation; among those citing division, 60 percent against 49 percent having lost patience with or yelled at a family member, 55 percent against 37 percent having canceled social plans, 61 percent against 43 percent feeling isolated often or some of the time; 92 percent agreeing relationships are a key source of meaning and purpose, family named by 77 percent). Online, fielded August 4 to 24, 2025, margin of error 2.5 percentage points.
American Psychiatric Association. Healthy Minds Poll news release, November 18, 2025 (32 percent worried about dealing with challenging family dynamics; 31 percent about loneliness; 61 percent looking forward to seeing family and friends). Fielded by Morning Consult November 4 to 5, 2025 among 2,203 US adults.
Pillemer K. Family rifts affect millions of Americans. The Conversation, 2021, reporting the Cornell Family Reconciliation Project (27 percent of US adults reporting a current estrangement; the pathways including harsh parenting, abuse or neglect, favoritism and sibling conflict, loss of contact after divorce, in-law conflict, conflict over wills and money, disapproval of core values and norm violations). Nationally representative survey of 1,340 US adults, 2019, plus in-depth interviews. Book: Pillemer K. Fault Lines: Fractured Families and How to Mend Them. Avery, 2020.
Reczek R, Stacey L, Thomeer MB. Parent-adult child estrangement in the United States by gender, race/ethnicity, and sexuality. Journal of Marriage and Family. 2023 (81 percent of mother estrangements and 69 percent of father estrangements ending in reconciliation). Drawn from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth 1979 and its child supplement, 1994 to 2018. We read these figures in the publishing university's research summary rather than the article itself.
Reczek R. Families We Lose: A New Explanation for Family Estrangement. NYU Press, 2026 (estrangement typically a last resort after years of mistreatment rather than an impulsive decision). In-depth interviews with 68 US adults in 2023; qualitative.
Scharp KM. You're Not Welcome Here: A grounded theory of family distancing. Communication Research. 2019;46(4):427 to 455 (estrangement as a continuum of eight components including communication quality and quantity, physical distance, presence or absence of emotion, affect, desire to reconcile, role reciprocity and legal action). Narrative accounts from 52 adult children.
Caughlin JP, Afifi TD. When is topic avoidance unsatisfying? Examining moderators of the association between avoidance and dissatisfaction. Human Communication Research. 2004;30(4):479 to 513 (the association moderated by motivations for avoiding; avoidance can be benign and even helpful in some relational circumstances). 114 parent and child pairs and 100 dating couples; cross-sectional.
Butler EA, Egloff B, Wilhelm FH, Smith NC, Erickson EA, Gross JJ. The social consequences of expressive suppression. Emotion. 2003;3(1):48 to 67 (suppression disrupting communication, reducing rapport and inhibiting relationship formation, and magnifying blood pressure responses in the suppressors' partners as well as in the suppressors; reappraisal not carrying these costs). We confirmed the design and the direction of the findings through secondary records; we were not able to read the full article, so no figures from it are quoted here.
Srivastava S, Tamir M, McGonigal KM, John OP, Gross JJ. The social costs of emotional suppression: A prospective study of the transition to college. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2009;96(4):883 to 897 (suppression predicting lower social support from friends, less closeness and lower social satisfaction; no significant relationship with peer-rated likability). 278 participants at baseline.
Holt-Lunstad J, Clark BD. Social stressors and cardiovascular response: Influence of ambivalent relationships and behavioral ambivalence. International Journal of Psychophysiology. 2014;93(3):381 to 389 (ambivalent friends producing higher heart rate and blood pressure reactivity during stress, with elevations persisting into recovery). 104 healthy young adults; friends rather than family members.
Warner BR, Colaner CW, Park J. Political difference and polarization in the family: The role of (non)accommodating communication for navigating identity differences. Journal of Social and Personal Relationships. 2021;38(2):564 to 585 (of the accommodation strategies tested, respecting divergent values the most influential in protecting shared family identity, and among the most damaged by the disagreement itself). Quota-stratified online panel of 833; cross-sectional.
Yeomans M, Minson J, Collins H, Chen F, Gino F. Conversational receptiveness: Improving engagement with opposing views. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes. 2020;160:131 to 148 (Studies 1A, 1B and 2 to 4; the four-part receptiveness recipe of positive statements rather than negations, explicit acknowledgment of understanding, naming points of agreement and hedging rather than speaking in absolutes; a content-agnostic instruction improving receptiveness with an effect size of 0.47; self-ratings not tracking behavior; more receptive people seen as more persuasive and more desirable future partners).
Eyal T, Steffel M, Epley N. Perspective mistaking: Accurately understanding the mind of another requires getting perspective, not taking perspective. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 2018;114(4):547 to 571 (25 experiments; perspective taking not improving accuracy while increasing confidence; accuracy improving when people obtained the other person's perspective directly).
Gollwitzer PM, Sheeran P. Implementation intentions and goal achievement: A meta-analysis of effects and processes. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology. 2006;38:69 to 119 (94 independent tests; if-then plans producing a medium to large effect on goal attainment, d of 0.65). This research concerns goal pursuit in general and did not study family gatherings.
Kaslow NJ (Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Emory University School of Medicine, and a past president of the American Psychological Association), quoted in Emory University, Under the holiday lights: 8 expert tips for managing stress and family dynamics this festive season, December 2024 (agree to disagree and I'd rather not get into that right now; redirecting to traditions, hobbies, trips and favorite memories; taking a brief pause outside; stepping away with a polite excuse). Expert recommendation rather than trial evidence.
Sezer O, Norton MI, Gino F, Vohs KD. Family rituals improve the holidays. Journal of the Association for Consumer Research. 2016;1(4):509 to 526 (three studies, 1,098 participants total; family rituals improving holiday enjoyment through amplified family closeness and greater involvement; the specific ritual mattering less than performing it as a group; individual rituals showing no meaningful effect; the benefit holding independently of how much participants liked their family members).
Cohn-Schwartz E, Gooldin S, Meiry L, Heidemann R, Bachner YG. The unique characteristics of families of choice and families of origin of older LGBTQ+ adults: are they related to mental health? Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology. 2026 (more chosen-family members associated with fewer depressive symptoms and better wellbeing). Cross-sectional survey of 432 LGBTQ+ adults aged 50 and over in Israel; not a general population finding.
From The Healing Journal
Tell us a little about what is going on, and we will match you with a therapist who fits.
Reach outOr call or text 602-698-5777
Free guide from our therapists
5 Simple Ways to Get the Most Out of Therapy
The advice our team gives most, in one short read.
Download Free Guide